ELA / LiteratureGrades 6-86 roles55 min1 class period
ELA / LiteratureGrades 6-86 roles55 min1 class period
Westbrook Middle School, Thursday afternoon. A three-week collaborative mural is half-painted-over. Six people were near the hallway between 3:15 and 3:45 PM. The principal wants answers before tomorrow's open house.
A student-painted mural was vandalized. Six witnesses tell their stories - each in their own voice, each shaped by their own bias. Read the accounts, question the gaps, reconstruct what happened, then see how close you got.
Core (4 groups), Standard (5 groups), Full (6 groups)
Learning Objectives
5 objectives
Standards
4 standards aligned
Where This Fits in Your Curriculum
Run this during your point of view or narrative perspective unit in middle school ELA, at the moment you want students to understand narrator reliability and cannot get there with a single text. Students need to be able to read a short first-person account and notice what it does not say. They do not need any prior work on cognitive bias or formal argumentation - the six accounts arrive in formats students already read fluently: a diary entry, a text thread, a group chat, a voice memo. What the game is teaching is triangulation: sorting fact from inference from speculation, and seeing how confidently people report things they never actually saw. Most groups name the wrong suspect, and that is the design. ELA teachers get unreliable narrators made physical. Anyone running a media literacy or eyewitness-testimony discussion can borrow it whole.
What Students Will Learn
Identify how point of view shapes a narrator's account of the same event
Distinguish between fact, inference, and speculation in a witness statement
Recognize common cognitive biases (confirmation, self-serving, confabulation) at work in everyday language
Corroborate claims by triangulating across multiple accounts
Cite specific textual evidence to support a reconstruction
Cases Included
CCSS RL.6.6 / RL.7.6 - Explain how an author develops the point of view of the narrator or speaker (6); analyze how an author develops and contrasts the points of view of different narrators (7)
CCSS RL.6-8.1 - Cite textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text
CCSS SL.6-8.1 - Engage effectively in a range of collaborative discussions
CCSS RI.6-8.8 - Trace and evaluate the argument and specific claims in a text, distinguishing claims supported by reasons and evidence from claims that are not
Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)
Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.
Self-AwarenessThe game names confirmation, self-serving, and confabulation bias inside each witness account and closes by asking students what they will question the next time they are certain they know what happened.
Social AwarenessSix witnesses narrate the same vandalism in six formats, so students trace how point of view and self-interest shape each account and learn not to dismiss the emotional Morgan or the excluded voice.
Responsible Decision-MakingAs a detective team in Round 3 students triangulate evidence across all accounts, distinguish fact from inference, and commit to a suspect or to 'unsolved,' citing at least three sources.
Flexible Class Sizes
Core (4 groups)
The four accounts that carry the central tension: the artist who found the damage, the accused, the authority who's already decided, and the eavesdropper next door. Works with smaller classes - good for 8 to 16 students.
Standard (5 groups)
Adds the bystander whose timeline omission becomes the puzzle's biggest gap. Best for 12 to 20 students.
Full (6 groups)
Adds Morgan, the new student cut from the project, whose letter is long and emotional. The fullest range of POVs and the hardest to triangulate. Best for 18 to 30 students.
How the Game Plays Out
Turn 1: Share
Every voice has its own format - listen for what each one is doing.
"What does each witness know - and how do they know it?"
Turn 2: Question
Cross-examine the gaps.
"Which witnesses can you triangulate against each other - and which gaps does nobody cover?"
Turn 3: Reconstruct
Build the timeline. Name a suspect.
"Whose version of events best fits ALL the evidence - not just the loudest evidence?"
Turn 4: Reveal & Debrief
The truth, the gap, and what it means.
"How sure were you about who did it - and what does that tell us about how confident we should be in our own judgments?"
Roles Your Students Will Play
6 teams. The teacher assigns students to teams when the game starts.
Alex (The Artist)
Jordan (The Bystander)
Sam (The Accused)
Riley (The Authority)
Morgan (The Outsider)
Casey (The Overheard)
Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet
One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.
Primary Sources
Every role includes real historical documents. Students read them because they need the information to make their case.
Key Terms Students Will Learn
Unreliable narratorPoint of viewFirst personOmniscient narratorBiasConfirmation biasConfabulationOmissionCorroborationContradictionCredibilityTestimonyInferencePerspectiveMotiveSelf-serving biasFramingCorroborating detail
After the Game: Debrief Questions
If your group grew certain about a suspect, name ONE specific moment when that certainty hardened - a question, an answer, a piece of phrasing. If your group never settled, name the moment you came closest.
If Casey's group played: Casey didn't lie, and neither did Casey's friends. But together, the group chat made up the laughter. Did 'Casey heard laughter' end up in any reconstruction as a fact? If it did, how? If it did not, what kept it out?
If you were Principal Reyes and you had all the accounts you heard in front of you tomorrow morning before the open house, what would you do?
Ready to run this in your classroom?
Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.