All simulations

Downstream

An acid spill is moving down the river overnight: six water districts read the chemistry and decide how much to treat - and both under- and over-treating fail.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
Science / Chemistry Grades 9-12 6 roles 60 min 1 class period
Science / Chemistry Grades 9-12 6 roles 60 min 1 class period
A six-district municipal water system, the morning after an upstream acid release. Present day, unnamed river, unnamed city.

An unattributed industrial release sends sulfuric acid down the river overnight, and six student teams run the six drinking-water plants that draw from it. Each team computes its own neutralising dose from its own certificate of analysis - a new lot in every round after the first - and both under-dosing and over-dosing send water to the mains that should not have gone there. Runs in 49 minutes as a single period (Rounds 1, 3, and 4), or 60 minutes with Round 2 added.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

60 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

6 roles

Class Sizes

Small (4 districts), Standard (5 districts), Full (6 districts)

Learning Objectives

5 objectives

Standards

5 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

This is an end-of-unit consolidation for a first-year chemistry stoichiometry unit, not first exposure. Students should already have been taught mass to moles, mole ratios from a balanced equation, and limiting reagent. What they will not have done is run all five steps at speed, under time pressure, with a consequence attached to the answer, using a percent-purity correction that many stoichiometry problems leave out. Every round is the same five steps on new numbers - mass of acid, moles of acid, mole ratio, mass of compound, assay correction - and the arithmetic is small enough that a student who understands the method finishes in three minutes and a student who has been pattern-matching does not finish at all. The percent-assay step is the diagnostic: it is the one that cannot be guessed from the shape of the problem. Teachers running Chemistry I or Honors Chemistry in grades 10 and 11 will recognise this as the review day before the unit test. It also serves an Environmental Science or a career and technical education water-treatment course, where the vocabulary is the point rather than the scaffolding.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

Small (4 districts)
Two treatment trains of two. Best for 8 to 20 students. Every seat still doses every round, and the chain is still real - each train has a head and a tail.
Standard (5 districts)
A three-seat train and a two-seat train. Best for 10 to 25 students. The three-seat train has a middle position, which is the seat that both inherits and passes on.
Full (6 districts)
Two treatment trains of three. Best for 12 to 30 students, stretching to 34. This is the configuration the timing budget is written for.

How the Game Plays Out

Turn 1: First Light
The morning after the release
"Where does a dose come from, and what do you do when the bag runs out?"
Turn 2: Six Certificates
One river, six deliveries
"Whose number is your number?"
Turn 3: The Choice
The stockpile opens
"What do you do when the cheap reagent runs out halfway?"
Turn 4: The Surge
The plume front arrives
"Who ends up with room to be a little bit wrong?"

Roles Your Students Will Play

6 roles across 2 factions. Each has different information, different goals, and different leverage. Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Cedar Run Water District
train a
Cedar Run treats water drawn from the upper reach, where the river is still narrow and fast. The plant is the oldest on the river and runs a conventional train: rapid mix, flocculation, sedimentation, filtration, and a chemical feed room that was rebuilt eight years ago. Its intake sits highest on the river, so it usually sees a plume first.

Design flow 2.0 megalitres per day. Chemical feed room rebuilt eight years ago with two redundant metering pumps. Raw-water pH probe and a bench titration kit in the lab. Clearwell holds about four hours of finished water, so a bad batch is caught quickly or not at all.

Goals
  • Finish every round with your own residual inside the in-spec band
  • Use the rationed compound the warehouse actually delivered before drawing caustic soda
  • Help the other districts on your train finish in spec or marginal - your Chief Operator grade needs them to
Mill Creek Water District
train a
Mill Creek runs the newest plant on the system, built to replace a 1950s facility that was demolished when the new one came online. It has the largest chemical storage on the river and the smallest clearwell, which means it can dose almost anything but has very little time to catch an error before the water is in the mains.

Design flow 1.5 megalitres per day. Two 40-tonne dry-chemical silos plus a bagged-product store. Online pH and alkalinity analysers reporting every 30 seconds. Clearwell holds about 90 minutes of finished water.

Goals
  • Finish every round with your own residual inside the in-spec band
  • Read the certificate of analysis on every delivery before computing a dose
  • Help the other districts on your train finish in spec or marginal - your Chief Operator grade needs them to
Stone Fork Water District
train a
Stone Fork sits where the river splits around a bedrock ledge, and the plant draws from the eastern channel. It has the largest design flow on the system and the longest distribution network, so its finished water spends a long time in pipe before it reaches a tap.

Design flow 2.5 megalitres per day, the largest on the system. Draws from the eastern channel below the ledge. About 190 kilometres of distribution main, some of it cast iron installed before 1940. Corrosion control is a standing operational concern in any pH excursion.

Goals
  • Finish every round with your own residual inside the in-spec band
  • Watch pH on both sides, because long detention in old main is where any swing in water chemistry does its damage
  • Help the other districts on your train finish in spec or marginal - your Chief Operator grade needs them to
Long Bend Water District
train b
Long Bend takes its name from the oxbow the river makes above the plant. The bend slows the current, so material that enters upstream arrives here later and more spread out than it does anywhere else on the system. The plant is mid-sized and well instrumented.

Design flow 1.8 megalitres per day. Intake below a slow oxbow, so an upstream plume arrives later and flatter. Jar-test bench with a six-place gang stirrer. Lime silo plus a bagged-product store for alternate reagents.

Goals
  • Finish every round with your own residual inside the in-spec band
  • Do not assume a slow arrival is a small one, because the same mass takes longer to pass
  • Help the other districts on your train finish in spec or marginal - your Chief Operator grade needs them to
Clay Shoals Water District
train b
Clay Shoals draws from a broad shallow reach where the river runs over banded clay. Turbidity here is chronically higher than anywhere else on the system, so the plant carries the largest coagulant feed and the operators are used to reading a jar test rather than trusting a single number.

Design flow 3.0 megalitres per day, the largest volume treated on the system. Chronically elevated raw-water turbidity from the clay shoal. Largest coagulant feed on the system. Two-stage flocculation basins.

Goals
  • Finish every round with your own residual inside the in-spec band
  • Treat the largest volume on the system without letting the size of the number hide an error in the ratio
  • Help the other districts on your train finish in spec or marginal - your Chief Operator grade needs them to
Otter Bank Water District
train b
Otter Bank is the last plant on the lower reach before the river leaves the service area. Its intake is the furthest downstream on the map. The chain order rotates every round, and in the rounds it sits at the tail, whatever the plants above it do not neutralise arrives on top of its own load.

Design flow 2.2 megalitres per day. Furthest downstream intake on the system. Outfall discharges to the river below the plant, and that discharge is not scored by anyone in this simulation. Bench titration kit and an online pH probe.

Goals
  • Finish every round with your own residual inside the in-spec band
  • Start with your own volume times concentration, then add what arrives from upstream
  • Help the other districts on your train finish in spec or marginal - your Chief Operator grade needs them to

Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet

One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.

Primary Sources

Every role includes real historical documents. Students read them because they need the information to make their case.

National Secondary Drinking Water Regulations, sulfate
Elevated Blood Lead Levels in Children Associated With the Flint Drinking Water Crisis - a summary of the finding
Flint Water Advisory Task Force, Final Report
Safe Drinking Water Act, operator certification

Key Terms Students Will Learn

stoichiometrymolemolar massmole ratiobalanced equationlimiting reagentexcess reagentassaycertificate of analysisneutralisationresidualdosealkalinityparts per millioneffluentconsent orderquicklimeslakingcoagulantstockpile

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. Did your jar and your neighbour's come out the same colour? Either way, what did the two of you do differently in the arithmetic?
  2. Did anyone over-dose because it felt safer? What did the extra base do to the district downstream, and what did it cost the city?
  3. 'Stoichiometric' means exactly the right proportion. Where else must a number be exactly right rather than merely large enough?
  4. Chief Operator was unreachable unless every other district on your treatment train also finished in spec or marginal - however perfect your own arithmetic was. Fair rule? What does it say about what being good at this job means?
  5. If your class played Round 4, one district was Chair and could decide how the stockpile was split. Who ended up with room to be a little bit wrong, and who had to be exactly right? Was that decided by chemistry?
  6. The real history. Flint, Michigan, 2014. The failure was not arithmetic at the bench. The water source was switched above the plant without corrosion control, and then for eighteen months officials told residents who reported rust-colored water, rashes, and sick children that the water was safe. A mother who kept her own samples, a pediatrician who counted lead levels in her patients, and an outside engineering team were all disbelieved before they were believed. (a) Everyone in this game had an instrument, and every number you argued over came off a meter this simulation believed without question. Who is not in this game at all? (b) The only trace of those people you saw all period was the public notice feed. What could they actually tell, from their own taps, that none of your meters measured? (c) Downstream has no resident seat on purpose - nobody in this room was asked to play being disbelieved. Was that the right call? What would the game have taught that it did not?
  7. Your tail district discharged its residual to the river. Nobody scored that. Should someone have? And the tail seat is the most exposed seat: part of what the districts above it leave untreated arrives on top of its own load. Who sat there, and what did it cost you?
  8. Everyone in this game had a plant, an operator, a lab, and a regulator who could serve a consent order. About one in eight people in the United States drinks from a private well: no operator, no advisory, no consent order, and nobody to serve one. If the release had reached a private well instead of an intake, who would have found it?
  9. The notices in this game went up in English and Spanish. In a real city, who does not get that notice?
  10. In this game, pipe age changed nobody's score, and every household was on the municipal system. Neither is true of a real city - and which neighbourhood has the oldest pipes is usually not an accident. Why might that be?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.