All simulations

Forge or Fall

Examine survival, loyalty, and command decisions at Valley Forge, 1777.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
U.S. History Grades 8-12 6 roles 54 min 1 class period
U.S. History Grades 8-12 6 roles 54 min 1 class period
Valley Forge, Pennsylvania - Winter 1777-1778

The Continental Army is bleeding out at Valley Forge - not from British bullets but from empty supply wagons, political backstabbing, and the growing suspicion that maybe this revolution is not worth dying for. Every person who could save it has a reason not to.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

74 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

6 roles

Class Sizes

Small Class (4 roles), Standard (6 roles)

Learning Objectives

6 objectives

Standards

7 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

Place this in the middle of your American Revolution unit, after independence is declared and before you teach the Articles of Confederation - it is the bridge between them. Students need to know the war is on and who Washington is. They do not need battle-by-battle military history, and they specifically do not need to have studied the Articles yet, because watching Congress fail to feed an army is a better introduction to weak central government than any list of weaknesses. What it teaches is that the Revolution nearly died of logistics and politics rather than British firepower, and that the men who deserted were making a choice students can name and defend. It serves 8th grade and high school U.S. History, and civics teachers who want students to want a Constitution.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

Small Class (4 roles)
Aide, Quartermaster, Farmer, Congress - covers the core supply crisis and political tension
Standard (6 roles)
All six roles - adds the Surgeon and Von Steuben for the full Valley Forge experience

How the Game Plays Out

Turn 1: The Arrival
December 1777
"Where do the army's limited resources go first?"
Turn 2: The Crisis
January 1778
"How do you handle desertion - and do you still trust your commander?"
Turn 3: The Breaking Point
February 1778
"Does the army attempt a desperate winter raid on a British supply depot?"
Turn 4: The Forge
March 1778
"Will this army survive to fight again?"

Roles Your Students Will Play

Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

The General's Shadow
You are John Laurens, aide-de-camp to General George Washington. You manage the camp's daily crisis - the death reports, the desertion numbers, the supply shortages, the letters Washington is too exhausted to write himself. You see everything. You know exactly how close this army is to total collapse. The question is how much of that truth you share with the others in this room. Washington relies on you. But even he does not know all the numbers you have seen. The mortality reports. The desertion tallies. The intelligence suggesting the British know exactly how weak you are. You are the only person in camp who has the full picture - and the full picture is terrifying.

Army Strength: over 12,000 soldiers arrived at Valley Forge. Your private tracker counts the men present and able to fight. It starts at 11,000. Your tracker shows the real numbers, and they are worse than anyone else thinks. If army strength drops below 6,000, the army can no longer take the field as a unit - Washington would have to break it into detachments just to feed it.

Goals
  • Keep the army alive through the winter - army strength must not collapse below the survival threshold
  • Maintain Washington's authority against the Conway Cabal political threat
  • Manage information flow strategically - too much honesty causes panic, too little causes bad decisions
The Empty Wagon
You are Thomas Jones, an officer in the Quartermaster Corps responsible for food, clothing, and supplies. The job is impossible. Congress authorized supplies that do not exist. Farmers will not sell for Continental currency. The roads are frozen mud. The previous Quartermaster General resigned in disgust. You are the person everyone blames but nobody helps. Here is the truth nobody wants to hear: there IS food in the region. Pennsylvania farms within 30 miles of camp have enough grain to feed the army for months. The problem is not supply - it is payment. Continental dollars are nearly worthless. Why would a farmer trade real food for fake money when British officers in Philadelphia pay in gold?

Supply Level (your private tracker): You know exactly what is available and where it can come from. In 1777 the army had three ways to get supplies, each with a hidden cost: (1) Impressment - seize from civilians by force, legal but destroys civilian support. (2) Continental dollars - pay the official rate, but farmers increasingly refuse. (3) French merchant deal - good supplies, but the merchant wants exclusive postwar trade rights.

Goals
  • Get enough food and supplies to the army to prevent starvation
  • Balance supplies against civilian support
  • Convince the group to prioritize supplies even when other needs seem more urgent
The Reluctant Patriot
You are Elizabeth Whitfield, a Pennsylvania farm owner living near Valley Forge. You supported the Revolution in 1776. You cheered when they read the Declaration of Independence in the town square. But that was before Continental soldiers started stealing your fence rails for firewood. Before they offered you paper money that buys nothing at the general store. Before your children started going hungry because the army needs your grain more than your family does. You are not a Loyalist. You are not a traitor. You are a parent trying to feed your family while a war you supported is eating your livelihood. And a British merchant keeps coming around with hard currency - real money that actually buys things.

Civilian Loyalty (your private tracker): You track how the local civilian population feels about the army. It moves when vote results are revealed. If civilian support collapses, the army loses its intelligence network, shelter, and any hope of local resupply. You also have a standing offer from a British agent: sell provisions to the Crown for gold.

Goals
  • Keep your family fed through the winter - you cannot give away everything
  • Maintain your community's support for the Revolution - but not at any price
  • Get fair compensation for any supplies you provide - Continental dollars are not fair compensation
The Politician
You are Henry Laurens, a delegate to the Continental Congress. You are supposed to fund and supply the army, but Congress is broke. The states will not send money. The currency you print becomes more worthless every week. And a growing faction - the Conway Cabal - is pushing to replace Washington with General Horatio Gates, who at least won a battle at Saratoga. You are not a villain. You are trapped. You declared independence and promised liberty, but you cannot feed the army that is fighting for it. Every dollar you print makes the inflation worse. Every promise you make to Washington, you break. And the states you represent refuse to give you the power to fix any of it.

Political Capital (private): Your standing in Congress. Vote results move it. Two options for funding: (1) Print more Continentals - fast money but hyperinflation makes currency even more worthless. (2) Request a French loan - real money but slow, and France will demand a "no separate peace" clause tying American foreign policy to French war aims. You also know about the Conway Cabal - the secret movement to replace Washington with Gates.

Goals
  • Keep the army funded without completely destroying the Continental dollar
  • Maintain Congressional authority over the military - a general with too much power is what you just rebelled against
  • Navigate the Conway Cabal - support or oppose Washington based on what serves the Revolution
The Surgeon's Diary
You are based on Dr. Albigence Waldo, a real Continental Army surgeon who kept a diary at Valley Forge. Your diary is one of the most vivid primary sources from the entire Revolution. You wrote: 'Poor food - hard lodging - cold weather - fatigue - nasty clothes - nasty cookery... Why are we sent here to starve and freeze?' You see the human cost in bodies. Disease kills far more soldiers than combat - typhus, dysentery, smallpox, pneumonia. The textbook myth is that soldiers died from the cold winter. The truth is they died from overcrowding, poor sanitation, and malnutrition. You know what could save them, but prevention requires resources nobody will allocate because they are 'just' medical supplies.

Disease Severity (your private tracker): You track the spread of disease through camp. Typhus and dysentery are the big killers. Two interventions: (1) Smallpox inoculation - works, but temporarily disables soldiers for 2-3 weeks. If the British attack during inoculation, it is catastrophic. (2) Sanitation reforms (latrines away from water, proper camp layout) - saves lives but requires labor from starving, exhausted men.

Goals
  • Reduce disease casualties - across the war disease killed more than twice as many as combat did, and at Valley Forge the British killed almost no one at all
  • Secure medical resources from the group's limited supply budget
  • Make the group understand that medicine is not a luxury - it is the difference between an army and a graveyard
The Foreigner
You are Friedrich Wilhelm von Steuben, a Prussian military officer who arrives at Valley Forge in February 1778. Your resume says you were a lieutenant general in the Prussian Army. The truth: you were a captain. You have inflated your rank because no one in America would listen to a captain. You do not speak English. You drill the men in French and German while translators shout orders behind you. But here is what you know that no American officer understands: this army's real problem is not just supplies. These men do not know how to be soldiers. They waste food because they do not know how to cook in an organized camp. They cannot march in formation. They do not maintain weapons. They have no unit cohesion. Training fixes ALL of this - but training requires time and energy from men who have neither.

Training Level (private): You track how well-drilled and disciplined the army is. It starts very low. It rises when a Training vote wins.

Goals
  • Transform this militia into a professional army through drill and training
  • Prove your value before your fake credentials are exposed
  • Balance pushing the men hard enough to improve versus breaking men who are already exhausted

Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet

One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.

Primary Sources

Every role includes real historical documents. Students read them because they need the information to make their case.

Washington's Letter to the Continental Congress
"Unless some great and capital change suddenly takes place in that line, this Army must inevitably be reduced to one or other of these three things: Starve, dissolve, or disperse in order to obtain subsistence in the best manner they can."
Diary of Dr. Albigence Waldo
"Poor food - hard lodging - cold weather - fatigue - nasty clothes - nasty cookery - vomit half my time - smoked out of my senses - the Devil is in it - I cannot endure it - Why are we sent here to starve and freeze?"
Washington's Letter to Congress on the Commissary
"This brought forth the only commissary in the purchasing line in this camp; and, with him, this melancholy and alarming truth, that he had not a single hoof of any kind to slaughter, and not more than twenty-five barrels of flour! From hence form an opinion of our situation when I add, that he could not tell when to expect any."
Farmers Around Valley Forge (summary)
Summary: Many farmers near Valley Forge did not want to sell food for Continental paper money, because it kept losing value. Soldiers burned fence rails for firewood. Farmers wanted payment in money that held its value.
Congress and Army Supply (summary)
Summary: Congress asked the states again and again to send food and supplies to the army. In January 1778 it sent a committee to the camp to look into the commissary and quartermaster departments. Congress could ask the states for help, but it had no power to force them.
Steuben's Own Account of His Model Company
"I commenced operations by drafting one hundred and twenty men from the line, whom I formed into a guard for the general-in-chief. I made this guard my military school. I drilled them myself twice a day ... and in a fortnight my company knew perfectly how to bear arms, had a military air, knew how to march, to form in column, deploy, and execute some little maneuvers with excellent precision."
Private Joseph Plumb Martin's Narrative
"We were now in a truly forlorn condition - no clothing, no provisions and as disheartened as need be. ... [W]e were now absolutely in danger of perishing, and that too, in the midst of a plentiful country. We then had but little, and often nothing to eat for days together."
Conway's Words About Washington, as Reported to Him
"Heaven has been determined to save your country, or a weak General and bad counsellors would have ruined it."
Martha Washington's Letter from Valley Forge
"I came to this place about the first of February, where I found the General very well. ... The General is encamped in what is called the Great Valley on the banks of the Schuylkill. Officers and men are chiefly in huts, which they say is tolerable comfortable; the army are as healthy as can well be expected in general."

Key Terms Students Will Learn

Valley ForgeContinental CongressContinental dollarArticles of ConfederationquartermastercommissaryforagingimpressmentConway Cabalfire caketyphusinoculationBaron von Steubendrilldesertioncamp followers

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. Did anyone hide or shade the truth during this game? Why?
  2. Was there a right answer to any of the resource allocation votes?
  3. Why didn't Congress just send supplies?
  4. Von Steuben lied about his rank. Was that okay?
  5. What would you have done in February 1778 - stayed or deserted?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.