All simulations

Probable Cause

Detectives on one case, judges for another. Prove it the way the law allows.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
Civics / U.S. Government Grades 8-12 8 roles 50 min 1 class period
Civics / U.S. Government Grades 8-12 8 roles 50 min 1 class period
The town of Alder Falls, the week after two thefts on the same Friday night: a band's storeroom and a bike co-op's cage.

Each table plays two sides of the law: detectives on a theft, and judges for another table. To search or arrest, a Runner walks a paper warrant over and argues for it, and at the end a court keeps only what was taken lawfully.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

50 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

8 roles

Class Sizes

4 tables, 6 tables, 8 tables

Learning Objectives

4 objectives

Standards

5 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

Probable Cause lands in a Civics or U.S. Government unit on the rights of the accused, grades 8 to 12, and fits a CTE Law Enforcement Services course. Students need no prior law: the bench card and two one-page sheets carry every rule they use. What they practise underneath the theft is the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement and probable cause, read from the judge's chair as well as the detective's; three searches that need no warrant (consent, curb trash, open view) and their limits; the Miranda warning in custody, and why the door is not custody; and the exclusionary rule, watched as it throws out true evidence and what a warrant built on it found. Each table answers for its own rulings, so students argue about what is enough rather than memorise it. Use it before a unit on Mapp v. Ohio or Miranda v. Arizona, or after one, to test what the class can apply.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

4 tables
8 to 20 students: 2 to 5 at a table, one Chromebook per table. 6 or 7 students: Pick your own tables, 3 of them.
6 tables
21 to 30 students: 3 to 5 at a table, one Chromebook per table.
8 tables
31 to 40 students: 4 or 5 at a table, one Chromebook per table.

Roles Your Students Will Play

Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Table 1
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 2
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 3
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 4
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 5
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 6
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 7
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.
Table 8
Your table is a team of detectives on a theft, and the judges for another table. To search a place or make a seizure, police usually need a warrant: a judge's written permission. Under the Fourth Amendment a judge signs only on probable cause. In custody, the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda warning protect a person's right to stay silent.
Goals
  • Work out who did it, and prove it with evidence the court keeps.
  • As judges, sign only on probable cause, and give a reason when you refuse.
  • Remember the exclusionary rule: evidence taken unlawfully is thrown out, and so is what was found because of it.

Key Terms Students Will Learn

probable causewarrantsearchseizureFourth AmendmentFifth AmendmentMiranda warningcustodyconsentopen viewtipexclusionary ruleevidencealibiprosecutorchain of custody

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. Pick one evidence sheet the court threw out, or one a table chose to Leave. What would police have had to do to get it, and whose right would that break? Why does a court throw out true evidence?
  2. Judges: which warrant was hardest to rule on, a live one or a last ruling? What did the Runner say, if there was one, and what was on the warrant? Why does only the warrant count?
  3. Two people rented one of the places in your case. One of them lied about Friday night and stole nothing. Tell that Friday and the week after from that person's side. What in the law stood between a lie and a conviction?
  4. At the door, nobody had to talk to you. Did they know that? Who is most likely to know it, and who is least?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.