All simulations

Stoneback

Invasive species and trophic cascades: manage a six-zone ecosystem in crisis.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
Life Science / Ecology Grades 6-8 6 roles 56 min 1 class period
Life Science / Ecology Grades 6-8 6 roles 56 min 1 class period
Crestwater Nature Reserve - a freshwater ecosystem in the Great Lakes region, present day

A state fisheries biologist just confirmed it: Stoneback in the Crestwater River. Six teams manage different parts of the reserve. Each team holds private monitoring data about their zone. Nobody has the complete picture. The Stoneback is already spreading faster than anyone realizes - but only by sharing data will any team understand how far the cascade has already gone.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

56 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

6 roles

Class Sizes

Core (4 groups), Standard (5-6 groups), Full (6 groups)

Learning Objectives

6 objectives

Standards

5 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

Slot this into your ecosystems and interdependence unit, after students can read a food web but before you teach invasive species directly. It is the lesson that makes MS-LS2-4 and MS-LS2-5 land in the same period. Students need producers, consumers, and the idea that populations depend on one another. They do NOT need the term trophic cascade, any prior invasive-species content, or Great Lakes background - the reserve hands them the organisms and the monitoring data. It teaches inference from partial evidence: each zone holds one piece, the cascade is only visible once the pieces are combined, and the Round 3 bass collapse punishes the teams that hoarded. The response rounds then force honest tradeoffs, like a barrier that also blocks native fish or a poison that kills a whole zone. The game's permit lead times (barriers 6-8 weeks, rotenone 10-12 weeks) are compressed into four rounds so the game fits one class period; Round 4 is not week 4 on the real permitting clock. Real rotenone projects often take months to years of planning. Life science teachers get the core ecology. An environmental science elective gets the conservation policy argument.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

Core (4 groups)
The invasion front, the spread highway, the monitoring chokepoint, and the decision hub. Works for classes of 12-16 students. Note: this preset has no Forest Interior or Upland Fringe, so the heron and vernal-pool cascade storylines do not run - the Bass Collapse event still fires but its Forest Interior beat is skipped.
Standard (5-6 groups)
Adds Forest Interior - the indirect impact zone that confuses students until the heron cascade hits. (Upland Fringe's hidden secondary front is only available in the Full, 6-zone preset - there is no 5-zone variant with Upland Fringe in place of Forest Interior.) Recommended for most classes of 16-24.
Full (6 groups)
All six zones. The Upland Fringe vernal pool colonization is the game's most alarming hidden data - when this group speaks up, the whole class recalibrates. Best for classes of 20-28.

Roles Your Students Will Play

6 roles across 2 factions. Each has different information, different goals, and different leverage. Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Aquatic Zone
field
You manage the main river channel of Crestwater Reserve - the invasion front. A state fisheries biologist just completed an electrofishing survey that found something nobody wanted to see. The Stoneback (Channa stonei) is an invasive predatory fish from East Asia. It has no natural predators in American freshwater. It can breathe air and survive hours out of water in moist conditions - which means it can wriggle through wet grass between connected water bodies during flood events. It was probably released from a live food fish tank. And it is already here. Your electrofishing data shows the population is much larger than anyone expected for an early-stage invasion. Creek chub - the primary prey fish in the main channel - are already collapsing. Largemouth bass juveniles are down sharply. Both species are critical food sources for birds that nest and forage throughout the reserve. You are the zone with the most alarming raw numbers. The question is whether you can make the other zones understand what these numbers mean before the cascade becomes irreversible.

ELECTROFISHING SURVEY - Crestwater River Main Channel (conducted 14 days ago) Stoneback population estimate: 340-480 individuals in main channel (high confidence) Stoneback juveniles confirmed: yes - active reproduction underway Estimated doubling time: 8-10 weeks under current conditions Native fish status: - Creek chub: 23% of 3-year baseline (critical decline) - Largemouth bass adult catch rate: down 31% from prior year - Largemouth bass juvenile catch rate: down 68% from prior year - Bluegill: holding at 74% of baseline (declining) - Crayfish: 61% of baseline (declining) Biologist field note: 'The creek chub collapse is faster than our models predicted. At current rates, the channel chub population may be functionally absent within 6-8 weeks. Whatever depends on creek chub as a prey source is already feeling this upstream of where we can measure it.'

Goals
  • Secure Reserve Response Fund resources for physical removal in the main channel before the population doubles again
  • Share creek chub data with Forest Interior so they can explain their heron nesting failures
  • Prevent Stoneback from reaching upstream reaches - work with Wildlife Corridor on barrier placement
Wetland Edge
field
You manage the Crestwater wetland complex - the marshes, inlet channels, and low-oxygen backwaters that border the main river. The wetland is the invasion's fastest lateral route. The Stoneback can tolerate low-oxygen water far better than most native fish. Wetlands that kill trout barely slow a Stoneback down. When the river floods and the water pushes into your zone, Stoneback push with it. And your amphibian monitoring data is showing exactly what happens when a Stoneback moves into a frog nursery. Bullfrog call indices are down 40% from your 3-year baseline. Green frogs are down 28%. A citizen monitoring volunteer has logged something alarming in the inlet channel. Your habitat connectivity map - three water corridors connecting the wetland to the river - is the most operationally important document in this simulation. Nobody else has it. Without your spread vector data, the other zones cannot predict where the invasion expands next. Without Aquatic Zone's population count, you cannot calculate how quickly your corridors will be overwhelmed.

AMPHIBIAN BREEDING SURVEY - Crestwater Wetland Complex (conducted 3 weeks ago) Bullfrog call index: 40% decline vs. 3-year baseline (significant) Green frog index: 28% decline vs. 3-year baseline (notable) Spring peeper: holding (less susceptible - eggs deposited before Stoneback arrived) Citizen monitoring note (submitted last week): 'Spotted large unfamiliar fish in inlet channel, approximately 18 inches, dark mottled coloring, aggressive behavior near nest site. Does not match any fish in my field guide. Reporting as unusual sighting.' Habitat connectivity map showing three water corridors: - Corridor A (northern inlet): 2.1m wide, perennial flow, HIGH RISK - direct river connection - Corridor B (central marsh channel): 0.8m wide, seasonal flow, MEDIUM RISK - floods during wet events - Corridor C (southern drainage ditch): 1.4m wide, perennial flow, MEDIUM-HIGH RISK Note: Stoneback can traverse Corridor B during flood events even when normally dry.

Goals
  • Share corridor map with Wildlife Corridor and Reserve Management so barriers can be placed correctly
  • Protect bullfrog breeding areas - the mink and heron food chain runs through your frogs
  • Argue for Barrier Installation in Round 2. Round 2 is the only round a barrier protects Wetland Edge.
Forest Interior
field
You manage the mature forest interior of Crestwater Reserve - the upland woodlands where great blue herons have nested for 14 years. Your zone has no direct Stoneback exposure. No fish data. No water monitoring. And yet your monitoring data is showing that something is catastrophically wrong. The heron colony that has used this forest for 14 consecutive breeding seasons is failing. Twelve of 31 nests were abandoned post-hatching this spring - the highest abandonment rate in the colony's recorded history. Fledgling survival is down 40%. Osprey chick weight at two of three monitored nests is below the threshold associated with adequate food supply. You don't know why. The biologist note says 'possible foraging disruption, no confirmed cause.' The herons feed almost exclusively on fish - creek chub, bluegill, small bass - from the main river channel and wetland margins. If the fish are gone, the herons starve. But you don't have fish data. You need to find someone who does. This is the most important connection in the game. Your data is the tree-level signal of an aquatic collapse. You just don't know it yet.

AUDUBON CHAPTER NESTING REPORT - Crestwater Great Blue Heron Colony (current season) Colony established: 14 years, same stand of mature cottonwood trees Total active nests this season: 31 (down from 38 prior year) Nests abandoned post-hatching: 12 (39% of nests - unprecedented) Fledgling survival to banding: 60% of expected (down 40% from 3-year average) Osprey monitoring (3 nests along river corridor): - Nest 1: feeding frequency reduced, chick weight BELOW normal threshold - Nest 2: feeding frequency reduced, chick weight BELOW normal threshold - Nest 3: feeding frequency normal, chick weight normal Biologist field note: 'Heron and osprey foraging disruption is consistent with prey fish decline in the main channel and wetland margins. Cannot confirm cause without fish survey data. Recommend cross-referencing with aquatic zone monitoring immediately. Fledgling cohort for this season may be a total loss if foraging conditions do not improve within 2 weeks.' Note on your zone: When you share this data with Aquatic Zone and learn about the creek chub collapse, the connection will be unmistakable.

Goals
  • Make the heron-creek chub connection explicit by Round 2 - your data is invisible until you share it
  • Advocate for habitat restoration actions that support heron foraging areas (wetland margins and shallow river sections)
  • Track osprey chick weight across rounds - it is a sensitive early indicator of whether actions are working
Upland Fringe / Vernal Pool
field
You manage the upland fringe of Crestwater Reserve, including an isolated seasonal vernal pool that fills each spring from snowmelt. Vernal pools are ecologically critical - they provide breeding habitat for amphibians, foraging for mink, and feeding stops for migratory birds. They are also isolated, which normally protects them from aquatic invasions. Except during floods. Last spring, the reserve experienced an unusually wet period. Floodwater from the Crestwater wetland complex pushed across the low upland gradient and briefly connected the vernal pool to the main drainage system. Something came in with the water. Your camera traps recorded a large unfamiliar fish in the pool during the event. Nobody filed a formal report. The camera image was unclear, and the pool was expected to dry out and disconnect. It did not fully dry. And the fish is still there. You have the most alarming piece of information in this entire simulation: the invasion is already further along than the official survey shows. By the time the reserve acts on Aquatic Zone's population data, the vernal pool colonization may be months ahead of any response. This information changes everything - if you share it.

CAMERA TRAP DATA - Upland Fringe Zone (full season) Mink activity at vernal pool outlet: DOWN 60% vs. prior year (significant decline) Great blue heron visits to vernal pool: 0 this season (down from regular weekly visits) Raccoon visits to vernal pool: 0 this season (unexplained) Muskrat: present and active (consistent with prior years) Beaver activity: present in main drainage channel CAMERA IMAGE (spring flood event, 6 weeks ago): 'Large dark-mottled fish, estimated 16-18 inches, observed in vernal pool during flood inundation period. Aggressive posture observed near pool edge. Species not identified in field. Image quality limited by lens condensation. No formal report filed - awaiting species confirmation.' Current vernal pool status: still holding water (delayed dry-down due to wet spring) Connection to main drainage: CURRENTLY DISCONNECTED (dry upland gradient between pool and wetland) Flood connection: reconnects during high-water events (expected 1-2 times per year) Note: If the fish in this image is Stoneback, this pool has been colonized for 6 weeks. It will reconnect to the wetland system during the next flood event.

Goals
  • Share the vernal pool camera image with Reserve Management and Wetland Edge as early as possible - this changes the entire response timeline
  • Determine whether the vernal pool Stoneback can be isolated and treated before it reconnects to the drainage system
  • Keep your own Zone Health up - the Zone Survival Trophy goes to the habitat zone with the highest Zone Health at game end.
Wildlife Corridor
field
You manage the stream corridor connecting Crestwater Reserve's upland zones to the main river system. The corridor is how everything moves - water, nutrients, fish, and invasives. It is also where a single well-placed barrier could stop upstream spread. You have eDNA surveillance data from five monitoring points along the corridor. Environmental DNA (eDNA) is genetic material shed by organisms into the water - a fish doesn't have to be caught to confirm its presence; it just has to swim there. Your eDNA data gives you the most precise map of Stoneback's northern extent that anyone has. Stoneback eDNA is confirmed at monitoring points 1, 2, 3, and 4. Point 5 (the headwaters end) is clean. Native fish eDNA diversity is declining at points 2 and 3. River otter activity - a reliable indicator of healthy fish populations - has dropped 35% at point 3. At point 3, where the corridor passes through a culvert crossing, a barrier installation would stop all upstream Stoneback movement. It would also permanently block native fish migration through that culvert. That tradeoff is not yours alone to make - but yours to define clearly for the group.

eDNA SURVEILLANCE - Wildlife Corridor (5 monitoring points, sampled 10 days ago) Point 1 (river interface): Stoneback eDNA CONFIRMED - high concentration Point 2 (lower corridor): Stoneback eDNA CONFIRMED - moderate concentration Point 3 (culvert crossing): Stoneback eDNA CONFIRMED - low concentration Point 4 (upper corridor): Stoneback eDNA CONFIRMED - trace level (recent arrival) Point 5 (headwaters): Stoneback eDNA NOT DETECTED - currently clean Native fish eDNA diversity index: - Points 1-2: declining (21% below baseline) - Points 3-4: holding (5% below baseline) - Point 5: normal Otter camera trap data: - Point 3: otter activity DOWN 35% from prior year - Point 5: otter activity normal Barrier cost estimate (point 3 culvert): - Electric barrier: $4,200 installation, stops Stoneback movement - Physical weir: $6,800 installation, more permanent - PERMANENT COST: both options block native fish migration through this culvert - State permit required (6-8 weeks) - available Round 2+ - Wildlife Corridor must confirm barrier location using eDNA data - cannot place blindly Key decision: If barrier is placed at point 3, Stoneback cannot reach Point 5 headwaters. Native fish also cannot use this corridor to migrate to headwaters spawning areas.

Goals
  • Share eDNA data with Reserve Management to justify barrier authorization funding from the Reserve Response Fund
  • Confirm the barrier location with your group before Round 2 so Barrier Installation can be funded as soon as it opens
  • Preserve Point 5 headwaters as a Stoneback-free refuge zone
Reserve Management
administration
You are the Reserve Management office - the decision hub for Crestwater Nature Reserve. You have access to the state agency communications, the authorization matrix for all management actions, and the hidden conditions that constrain what the group can actually do. Your most important document is the Authorization Matrix, which tells everyone exactly what each action requires and when it becomes available. Physical removal is self-authorized. Barrier installation requires a state permit with a 6-8 week lead time - meaning a barrier cannot be placed before Round 2. Rotenone requires state and federal EPA authorization - available Round 4 only. You also hold an unconfirmed sighting report from the adjacent reservoir. If confirmed, it means the source of the original introduction is still active and could re-seed Crestwater even after successful eradication. Your role is not passive. You are the communication hub - you facilitate the Reserve Response Fund allocation decisions each round, hold the conditions card, and are the only zone that can formally authorize barrier installation and rotenone treatment. Your transparency or opacity directly determines how well the group allocates resources. IMPORTANT - HIDDEN CONDITIONS CARD (do not volunteer this unless asked about the reservoir): An unconfirmed Stoneback sighting was reported at Clearwater Reservoir (adjacent watershed) last month. If confirmed, this means the introduction source is still active and re-seeding is possible even after successful eradication. Reveal this only when the group specifically asks about long-term strategy or re-invasion risk.

STATE WILDLIFE AGENCY MEMO - Crestwater Reserve Management Formal Stoneback (Channa stonei) identification: CONFIRMED Confirmation date: 14 days ago Source of introduction: unknown (suspected aquarium release from pet trade) AUTHORIZATION MATRIX: - Electrofishing / Physical Removal: Reserve can self-authorize. Available immediately. - Barrier Installation: State permit required (DNR Form 44-B). Processing: 6-8 weeks. Available in the game from Round 2. - Coordinated Monitoring (eDNA + electrofishing): Self-authorize. Available immediately. - Habitat Restoration: Self-authorize. Available immediately. - Rotenone Treatment (piscicide): Requires state authorization + federal EPA notification. Timeline: 10-12 weeks. EARLIEST AVAILABILITY: Round 4. Will require public comment period. RESERVE RESPONSE FUND: 8 points each round, shared by every zone. Every zone submits one recommendation per round on its Recommendations tab. Each one is that zone's action. Your Dashboard adds up the points. If the total is over 8, zones must change theirs. An action the fund cannot cover does nothing. Lead the room to a plan that fits. NOTE: Adjacent watershed (Clearwater Reservoir): Unconfirmed Stoneback sighting reported last month. Investigation pending. If confirmed, re-seeding risk must be factored into long-term strategy.

Goals
  • Make sure every zone knows the authorization timeline - Barrier Installation opens in Round 2 and Rotenone in Round 4
  • Facilitate Reserve Response Fund allocation fairly and transparently each round
  • Get Wildlife Corridor's barrier location ready so Barrier Installation can be funded in Round 2

Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet

One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.

Primary Sources

Every role includes real historical documents. Students read them because they need the information to make their case.

Electrofishing Survey - Crestwater River Main Channel
"Survey methodology: 2.1 km of main channel, backpack electrofishing, 3 passes. Creek chub capture rate 23% of 3-year baseline. Largemouth bass juvenile CPUE (catch per unit effort) 68% below expected. Stoneback confirmed: 47 individuals captured and released for tracking, with visual observation suggesting total population 340-480 in surveyed section. Estimated doubling time based on density-dependent growth curves: 8-10 weeks. Recommendation: immediate coordinated response. This population is not in early establishment - it is in exponential growth phase."
Wetland Amphibian Breeding Survey
"Call count transects completed May 3-7. Bullfrog (Lithobates catesbeianus): 18 calling males counted vs. 3-year average of 30.4 (40% decline). Green frog (Lithobates clamitans): 22 calling males vs. 3-year average of 30.6 (28% decline). Spring peeper: holding at baseline. Anomalous sighting: citizen monitor Sarah K. reports 'large unfamiliar fish, approximately 18 inches, dark mottled, aggressive near nest' in northern inlet channel on May 11. Species unconfirmed. Recommend follow-up electrofishing survey of inlet channels."
Great Blue Heron Colony Nesting Report - Crestwater Forest Interior
"Colony established 2011, continuously occupied for 14 breeding seasons. Current season nest count: 31 (down from 38). Post-hatching abandonment: 12 nests. Abandonment rate: 38.7% - the highest in the colony's recorded history. Previous high: 14% (drought year, 2018). Fledgling production estimated 40% below 3-year average. Osprey monitoring summary: 2 of 3 nests showing reduced food delivery frequency. Chick weight measurements at these nests: 650g and 710g vs. target 850g+ at this growth stage. Biologist note: 'Foraging disruption hypothesis cannot be confirmed without cross-referencing aquatic monitoring data. The timing and pattern of nest abandonment is consistent with a sudden prey fish decline in foraging range (river channel and wetland margin).'"
Camera Trap Summary - Upland Fringe and Vernal Pool
"Camera trap deployment: 8 units across upland fringe and vernal pool perimeter. Notable findings: Mink (Neovison vison) detections at vernal pool outlet: 14 events this season vs. 35 events prior year (60% decline). Great blue heron detections: 0 this season vs. 8 prior year. Raccoon detections at vernal pool: 0 this season vs. 12 prior year. During spring flood event (April 18-21): Camera 4 (vernal pool, east bank) captured image of large unidentified fish in pool, estimated 16-18 inches, dark dorsal pattern, present for 48-hour inundation period. Pool has not fully dried down this season due to extended wet period."
Environmental DNA Surveillance Report - Wildlife Corridor
"eDNA water samples collected from 5 monitoring points along stream corridor. Lab analysis via quantitative PCR using Stoneback-specific primers. Results: Point 1 (river interface): POSITIVE, Cq value 18.4 (high concentration). Point 2 (lower corridor, 400m upstream): POSITIVE, Cq value 24.1 (moderate). Point 3 (culvert crossing, 800m upstream): POSITIVE, Cq value 29.7 (low - recent arrival). Point 4 (upper corridor, 1200m upstream): POSITIVE, Cq value 33.2 (trace). Point 5 (headwaters, 1600m upstream): NEGATIVE. The eDNA front is advancing at approximately 100-150m per week. At current rate, Point 5 will show positive results within 2-4 weeks."
State Wildlife Agency Memo - Crestwater Stoneback Response
"TO: Crestwater Nature Reserve Management RE: Confirmed Stoneback (Channa stonei) detection, authorization guidance Species confirmed via electrofishing survey (Dr. Vasquez, attached). This triggers Tier 2 invasive species response protocol. Reserve Management is authorized to proceed with physical removal and coordinated monitoring immediately under existing reserve permits. Barrier installation (physical or electrical) requires Form 44-B, estimated processing 6-8 weeks from submission. Rotenone treatment requires this office's written authorization and federal and state pesticide permits - earliest realistic timeline is 10-12 weeks from application. We strongly recommend beginning barrier permit application immediately if that option is under consideration. Note: DNR Wildlife Division is investigating a possible Stoneback sighting at Clearwater Reservoir (adjacent watershed). No confirmation yet. Reserve Management should assume this is an independent introduction, but if confirmed, long-term strategy must account for re-seeding risk."

Key Terms Students Will Learn

invasive speciesbiodiversity indextrophic cascadeapex predatorelectrofishingrotenoneeDNA (environmental DNA)riparianpiscicidetrophic levelnative specieskeystone speciesbiological controlpopulation densityecosystem services

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. (Skip if no group held Forest Interior.) Forest Interior: did you figure out why your data mattered? If so, when, and what made the connection?
  2. Aquatic Zone: if you could have shared one piece of your data in Round 1 before any other team did anything - what would it have been? Why?
  3. Did anyone use Rotenone? What would you have had to believe was true to think that was the right call?
  4. What decision does the group regret most? What information did you have - or not have - that led to that decision?
  5. The Stoneback is not evil. It is just doing what it evolved to do. What does that mean for how we think about the management choices?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.