All simulations

Story Autopsy

Every team gets the same short story with its sections shuffled - arrange it, then defend why your structure makes the stronger meaning.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
ELA / Literature Grades 6-8 6 roles 55 min 1 class period
ELA / Literature Grades 6-8 6 roles 55 min 1 class period
A literary workshop where student teams act as editors analyzing the structure of an original short story. The story follows Alex, a teenager who finds their best friend's journal and faces a decision that changes both their lives. The same facts, arranged differently, tell a completely different story.

Every team reads the same short story - but the sections are shuffled. Arrange them into the structure that creates the most powerful meaning, then defend your choices. There is no right answer. Only stronger and weaker arguments about how stories are built.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

55 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

6 roles

Class Sizes

Core (4 groups), Standard (5-6 groups)

Learning Objectives

5 objectives

Standards

5 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

This belongs in your short story unit, right where you would normally teach plot structure - after students have read a couple of stories and can name a climax, and before you hand them flashback, frame narrative, and in medias res. They do NOT need those terms coming in, and they do not need to have read anything specific: the story is written into the game and every team reads the same seven sections. What it is teaching is that structure is a choice a writer makes rather than a shape a story arrives in, and that a claim about meaning has to be defended with evidence when there is no answer key to appeal to. Middle school ELA teachers get RL.6.5 and RL.8.5 as an argument instead of a diagram. Creative writing teachers get the strongest case they will ever make for revising by rearranging.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

Core (4 groups)
Four editorial teams. Works well for classes of 12-20 students.
Standard (5-6 groups)
All six editorial teams. Best for classes of 20-30 for maximum interpretive diversity.

How the Game Plays Out

Turn 1: The Read
Discover the story
"What is this story about, and what questions does it raise?"
Turn 2: The Build
Arrange the story your way
"How does the order you chose change what the story means?"
Turn 3: The Autopsy
Cut the story open
"What did other teams find that your team missed?"
Turn 4: The Debrief
What the story teaches about stories
"How does what you learned here change how you'll read the next book?"

Roles Your Students Will Play

6 roles across 6 factions. Each has different information, different goals, and different leverage. Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Margin Notes
margin notes
Your editorial team reads closely and annotates everything. You catch the details other readers miss - a word choice that seems off, a detail that comes back later, a silence where you expected speech. Your job is to read this story, arrange its sections into the most powerful structure you can build, and defend your choices with evidence from the text.
  • Close readers who catch details
  • Annotate everything
  • Evidence-driven arguments
Goals
  • Arrange the story sections into a structure that creates the strongest possible meaning
  • Write a theme statement that captures what your arrangement reveals
  • Contribute discoveries to the class map during the Autopsy round
Underlined
underlined
Your editorial team focuses on what matters most. You underline the sentences that carry the weight of the story - the turning points, the key revelations, the moments where everything shifts. Your job is to read this story, arrange its sections into the most powerful structure you can build, and defend your choices with evidence from the text.
  • Focus on key moments and turning points
  • Identify what carries the story's weight
  • Structural thinkers
Goals
  • Arrange the story sections into a structure that creates the strongest possible meaning
  • Write a theme statement that captures what your arrangement reveals
  • Contribute discoveries to the class map during the Autopsy round
Bookmarked
bookmarked
Your editorial team marks the passages worth returning to. You bookmark the moments that change meaning when you reread them - the lines that seem ordinary the first time but devastating the second. Your job is to read this story, arrange its sections into the most powerful structure you can build, and defend your choices with evidence from the text.
  • Rereaders who find deeper meaning
  • Notice how context changes interpretation
  • Patient and thorough
Goals
  • Arrange the story sections into a structure that creates the strongest possible meaning
  • Write a theme statement that captures what your arrangement reveals
  • Contribute discoveries to the class map during the Autopsy round
Dog-Eared
dog eared
Your editorial team bends the pages at the parts that hit hardest. You dog-ear the sections that provoke the strongest emotional response - the moments that make you angry, sad, conflicted, or surprised. Your job is to read this story, arrange its sections into the most powerful structure you can build, and defend your choices with evidence from the text.
  • Emotional readers who track impact
  • Identify what provokes the strongest response
  • Gut-level reactions backed by evidence
Goals
  • Arrange the story sections into a structure that creates the strongest possible meaning
  • Write a theme statement that captures what your arrangement reveals
  • Contribute discoveries to the class map during the Autopsy round
Highlighted
highlighted
Your editorial team highlights the patterns. You track the images, words, and ideas that repeat across sections - the motifs that build meaning through repetition. Your job is to read this story, arrange its sections into the most powerful structure you can build, and defend your choices with evidence from the text.
  • Pattern finders who track motifs
  • See connections across sections
  • Big-picture thinkers
Goals
  • Arrange the story sections into a structure that creates the strongest possible meaning
  • Write a theme statement that captures what your arrangement reveals
  • Contribute discoveries to the class map during the Autopsy round
Between the Lines
between the lines
Your editorial team reads what is NOT on the page. You notice the silences - what characters don't say, what the narrator skips over, what questions the text raises but never answers. Your job is to read this story, arrange its sections into the most powerful structure you can build, and defend your choices with evidence from the text.
  • Read the silences and gaps
  • Notice what's missing from the text
  • Ask questions the story doesn't answer
Goals
  • Arrange the story sections into a structure that creates the strongest possible meaning
  • Write a theme statement that captures what your arrangement reveals
  • Contribute discoveries to the class map during the Autopsy round

Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet

One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.

Key Terms Students Will Learn

narrative structurethememotifsymbolismdramatic ironypoint of viewdictiontoneambiguityexpositionrising actionmoral complexityexpulsioncode of conductinsight

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. Would the same seven sections in a different order tell a different story? Compare your order with another team's if you can. What does that tell you about how structure shapes meaning?
  2. Which section would you put first, and which last? Why?
  3. The torn page is the central symbol of this story. How did your arrangement affect what the torn page MEANS?
  4. Was Alex right to turn in the journal? Was Alex right to tear out the page? Could Alex be right both times?
  5. When you read a novel, the author already arranged the story for you. Now that you've done it yourself, what will you notice about their choices that you wouldn't have noticed before?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.