ELA / Science / Social StudiesGrades 6-106 roles52 min1 class period
ELA / Science / Social StudiesGrades 6-106 roles52 min1 class period
A formal inquiry commission convened to investigate a crisis - three selectable scenarios: a bee colony collapse, a municipal water contamination crisis, or a catastrophic wildfire
A CER simulation in three fully separate, replayable storylines - bee colony collapse, water contamination, or wildfire. Each scenario has different roles, evidence, and expert witnesses. Your team has been assigned a cause and your job is to prove it is the most important one. Student teams act as expert witnesses before a formal inquiry commission investigating a real crisis. Four to six teams each argue that their assigned cause is the MOST IMPORTANT cause of a shared disaster. But testimony alone is not enough: in cross-examination, teams must identify exactly where rival reasoning fails - not just disagree with the claim, but find the gap between the evidence and the logic connecting it to the claim. That gap is where most arguments fall apart, and that gap is what this commission is judging.
Core (4 teams), Standard (5 teams), Full (6 teams)
Learning Objectives
5 objectives
Standards
11 standards aligned
Where This Fits in Your Curriculum
Drop this in wherever you teach argumentation: a science teacher's CER unit, an ELA argumentative writing unit, or a civics unit on evidence and public policy. Students need to know what a claim, evidence, and reasoning are. They do not need to know anything about bees, lead pipes, or wildfire behavior, because each scenario's exhibit packet supplies the content. The real skill is the one CER instruction usually skips: attacking the reasoning instead of the claim. Cross-examination forces a team to name the exact gap between a rival's evidence and its conclusion, then defend their own when it happens back to them. Run it as a mid-unit practice run before a written argument essay, or as the performance task at the end of one. Three scenarios means you can run it with a second section, or a second year, without students trading answers.
What Students Will Learn
Construct a CER argument with a specific, defensible claim supported by relevant evidence and explicit reasoning that explains why the evidence supports the claim
Evaluate the quality of another team's reasoning by identifying gaps in the logical connection between evidence and claim - not just expressing disagreement
Revise an argument in response to a specific challenge, strengthening the reasoning without abandoning the original claim
Distinguish between correlation and causation when evaluating evidence presented by self and others
Understand that complex crises typically have multiple contributing causes, and that the question of 'most important' requires explicit reasoning about mechanism and scale - not just more evidence
Cases Included
NGSS SEP 7 (6-8): Construct an argument supported by evidence for how phenomena or solutions to design problems are supported or not supported by data
NGSS SEP 7 (9-12): Construct, use, and present oral and written arguments supported by empirical evidence and scientific reasoning
CCSS WHST.6-8.1: Write arguments focused on discipline-specific content
CCSS WHST.9-10.1: Write arguments focused on discipline-specific content
CCSS W.8.1: Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence
CCSS W.9-10.1: Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence
CCSS RST.6-8.8: Distinguish among facts, reasoned judgment, and speculation in a text
CCSS RST.9-10.8: Assess the extent to which the reasoning and evidence in a text support the author's claims
CCSS SL.8.3: Delineate a speaker's argument and specific claims, evaluating the soundness of the reasoning
CCSS SL.8.4: Present claims and findings, emphasizing salient points in a focused, coherent manner
C3 D4.1.6-8: Construct arguments using claims and evidence from multiple sources
Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)
Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.
Responsible Decision-MakingIn cross-examination teams must locate the exact gap between a rival's evidence and its claim and distinguish correlation from causation, and the commission judges the soundness of that reasoning.
Social AwarenessEach team argues one assigned cause of a shared crisis (mites, pesticides, habitat, climate, or the water crisis's engineering, policy, and justice angles), so students grasp why a complex disaster has multiple genuine contributing perspectives rather than one villain.
Relationship SkillsTeams construct a CER argument, present it as expert witnesses, cross-examine rivals, and revise their reasoning in response to a specific challenge without abandoning the claim.
Flexible Class Sizes
Core (4 teams)
Four expert witness teams covering the most clearly contrasting causes. Enough perspective for strong cross-examination without too many teams to manage.
Standard (5 teams)
Adds a fifth expert witness perspective. Recommended for most classes - more cross-examination targets and richer deliberation.
Full (6 teams)
Adds a sixth expert witness team. In Hollow Creek, this team (the epidemiologist) challenges the framing itself - arguing 'most important cause' is the wrong question. In Cedarville and Ridgeline, this team (the journalist / the human-factors investigator) instead argues a sixth distinct cause - information suppression, or a systemic accountability failure - that cuts across the other five. Either way, it sharpens everyone's reasoning by forcing the room to defend the premise of the inquiry as well as their own cause.
How the Game Plays Out
Turn 1: Testimony Preparation
Build Your Case
"What claim will your team make, and what evidence and reasoning will you use to support it?"
Turn 2: Cross-Examination
Challenge the Reasoning
"Where does the rival team's reasoning fail to explain the logical connection between their evidence and their claim?"
Turn 3: Commission Findings
Reach a Verdict
"Which argument was most convincing - and what specifically made the reasoning strong?"
Roles Your Students Will Play
Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet
One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.
Primary Sources
Every role includes real historical documents. Students read them because they need the information to make their case.
Key Terms Students Will Learn
claimevidencereasoningcounterclaimcross-examinationtestimonyexpert witnesscommissionfindingsinferencecorrelationcausationprimary sourceburden of proofrebuttal
After the Game: Debrief Questions
Which team's reasoning did you find most convincing - and what specifically made it strong?
What is the difference between just citing evidence and actually explaining how it supports a claim?
Did anyone change their mind during cross-examination - either about their own cause or about a rival team's argument? What changed it?
If every cause argued today contributed to this crisis, why does it matter to identify which one was 'most important'?
How is what we did today similar to how scientists, journalists, lawyers, and policymakers actually argue about contested issues in the real world?
If your team wrote a challenge, what was the hardest part of writing it - and what does that tell you about what makes reasoning hard to attack?
Ready to run this in your classroom?
Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.