All simulations

The Witness

A school hearing. One witness who cannot lie. Only what Casey says counts.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
ELA / Argumentation Grades 6-10 9 roles 50 min 1 class period
ELA / Argumentation Grades 6-10 9 roles 50 min 1 class period
Hollis High School, the morning after the hawk mascot costume vanished, at a school hearing in the library conference room.

A classmate sits as Casey, a witness who can never lie but may refuse three questions, and groups question Casey from their own paper evidence files, then argue their story citing only the numbered lines Casey actually said.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

50 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

9 roles

Class Sizes

3 groups, 4 groups, 5 groups, 6 groups, 7 groups, 8 groups

Learning Objectives

5 objectives

Standards

5 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

The Witness lands in an argument-writing or informational-reading unit in grades 6-10, right before students write their first claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph or answer a counterclaim. Students need no background on the case and no debate experience; they only need to know what a claim is. A classmate plays Casey, a witness who can never lie but may refuse three questions, and groups choose printed questions from their own paper evidence files to put lines on a public record. Each group then writes a short brief that may cite only numbered lines of what Casey actually said, and an answer key scores each cited line by whether it really backs the group's story. Underneath the mystery, students practice choosing the most relevant evidence, telling a line that fits every story from one that decides between them, and answering the strongest line against their own claim. It suits ELA teachers, social studies teachers teaching sourcing, and anyone teaching argument.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

3 groups
8-13 students. Scene also holds Statements; Digital also holds Background. Plus the witness pair.
4 groups
14-17 students. Digital also holds Background. Plus the witness pair.
5 groups
18-23 students. One file each. Plus the witness pair.
6 groups
24-27 students. Records A and Records B hold the same file. Plus the witness pair.
7 groups
28-32 students, the usual class. Records and Digital each go to an A and a B group. Plus the witness pair.
8 groups
33-42 students. Records, Digital and Statements each go to an A and a B group. Two days is recommended.

Roles Your Students Will Play

Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Casey Morrow
You play Casey Morrow, the student equipment manager, at a sworn school hearing. Casey is a character, not you. Your device shows Casey's card and the one true sentence for each question.
Goals
  • Say only the sentence on your screen, then tap Answer.
  • You may refuse three questions in the whole hearing, out loud: "I'd rather not answer that."
  • Keep Casey's secret off the record if you can. It earns no points either way.
Records
Your envelope holds Records: logs and schedules. The practice schedule, the equipment room door log, a work order and the library sign-in.
Goals
  • Ask Casey the printed questions on your items.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Scene
Your envelope holds Scene: the scene report. Where the costume was found, the loft ladder, the loft floor and the equipment room door.
Goals
  • Ask Casey the printed questions on your items.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Digital
Your envelope holds Digital: posts and chats. A draft post, a text message, a Westbrook story post and the team group chat.
Goals
  • Ask Casey the printed questions on your items.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Statements
Your envelope holds Statements: what people saw. Signed statements from Mr. Ward, Sam Bell and Ms. Ferris.
Goals
  • Ask Casey the printed questions on your items.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Background
Your envelope holds Background: who wanted what. The yearbook deadline, an old post, the musical sign-up and the hype videos.
Goals
  • Ask Casey the printed questions on your items.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Records B
Your envelope holds the same file as Records A, with a big B on it: logs and schedules. A question either group gets answered is closed for both.
Goals
  • Have a backup question ready: Records A asks before you each round and may ask the question you picked.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Digital B
Your envelope holds the same file as Digital A, with a big B on it: posts and chats. A question either group gets answered is closed for both.
Goals
  • Have a backup question ready: Digital A asks before you each round and may ask the question you picked.
  • Label each new line for the story your group backs.
  • Write a brief that cites the lines that back your story.
Statements B

Key Terms Students Will Learn

claimevidencereasoningciterelevantsufficientcorroboratecounterclaimred herringinferencetestimonyoathalibi

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. Did Casey refuse any questions? If so, did anyone decide Casey was guilty because of a refusal? Would that be fair if Casey were innocent?
  2. Look at two reasons. Which reason says why its line matters, and which one only repeats the line?
  3. Is there a line on the record that backs two stories? If so, what question would tell those two stories apart?
  4. Which question could have sunk your story? Did you ask it?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.