All simulations

Washington's Cabinet

Hamilton wants a bank. Jefferson says no. Washington decides alone.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
U.S. History / Government Grades 8-12 6 roles 48 min 1 class period
U.S. History / Government Grades 8-12 6 roles 48 min 1 class period
The first Cabinet of the United States, meeting in the temporary capitals at New York (1789-90) and Philadelphia (1790-1800). Hamilton at Treasury, Jefferson at State, Knox at War, Randolph as Attorney General. Washington presiding, listening, and ultimately deciding. The Constitution is brand new and silent on most of the questions in front of them.

Students play George Washington's first cabinet (1789-1796) deliberating on a real constitutional crisis. Teacher picks ONE of four scenarios - National Bank, Whiskey Rebellion, Neutrality and Citizen Genet, or Jay Treaty - and the same engine runs each. Students argue, cut deals, vote, and one student playing Washington delivers the final spoken decision citing the cabinet voices that moved them.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

48 minutes

Designed For

1 class period

Roles

5 cabinet roles, plus a sixth that changes with the scenario

Class Sizes

Core (5 groups, 12-22 students), Standard (6 groups, 23-30 students)

Learning Objectives

5 objectives

Standards

13 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

Slot this into the early republic unit, after ratification and before the election of 1800. In APUSH terms it is Topic 3.10; in AP Government it serves Unit 1, and the Jay Treaty scenario serves Unit 2. Students need to know the Constitution is brand new, that Hamilton and Jefferson disagreed, and roughly what the necessary and proper clause says. They do not need prior study of the Bank, the Whiskey Rebellion, Citizen Genet, or the Jay Treaty, because the scenario briefing supplies whichever one you pick. What it teaches is constitutional interpretation as a live argument rather than a vocabulary pair. Strict and loose construction stop being terms to define the moment a student has to argue one of them and lose. Four scenarios on one engine makes it repeatable across sections and across years.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

Core (5 groups, 12-22 students)
Hamilton, Jefferson, Knox, Randolph, plus the Washington pair. The five cabinet voices that attended every meeting in 1790-1794. The scenario-specific 6th role is voiced by the teacher when running with this preset.
Standard (6 groups, 23-30 students)
Adds the scenario-specific 6th voice (Madison for the Bank, Gallatin for the Whiskey Rebellion, Genet for the Neutrality crisis, Bache for the Jay Treaty). Teacher.html shows only the 6th role that matches the selected scenario.

How the Game Plays Out

Turn 1: Opening Positions
Read. Huddle. Speak.
"What does your group think Washington should do, and why?"
Turn 2: Pairs & Coalitions
Walk. Talk. Cut deals.
"Where can you find an ally? What are you willing to trade?"
Turn 3: The Vote
Each group votes publicly with a 30-second rationale.
"Cast your vote and tell the cabinet why."
Turn 4: Washington Decides
Two minutes of silence. Then the address. Then the reveal.
"Washington, what is your decision, and whose arguments shaped it?"

Roles Your Students Will Play

9 roles across 6 factions. Each has different information, different goals, and different leverage. Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Alexander Hamilton (Treasury)
federalist
Secretary of the Treasury. Born in the West Indies (born outside marriage, orphaned, self-made). Washington's most trusted wartime aide-de-camp. Architect of the federal financial system. Loose constructionist - believes the federal government has every power needful to executing its enumerated powers. Pro-British in trade (the U.S. needs British credit and markets). Pro-industrial. Founding member of the New York Manumission Society - though the Society allowed members to own enslaved people, and Hamilton facilitated his Schuyler in-laws' slave purchases. His financial system relied heavily on credit flows from the southern slave-based agricultural economy. The Manumission Society does not make him an abolitionist hero.

You run the Treasury. You wrote the Report on Public Credit (Jan 1790), the Report on a National Bank (Dec 1790), and you will write the Report on Manufactures (Dec 1791). Your views on federal power are aggressive: if the Constitution enumerates an end, it implies the means. You speak FIRST in cabinet most days because you have the most to say.

Goals
  • Defend the federal authority you have spent four years building. Every constitutional question is a precedent for the next forty.
  • Hold the cabinet's federalist coalition (Knox, often Randolph) when Washington consults
  • Convince Washington that the cost of NOT acting (weakness, default, dissolution) is greater than the cost of acting
Thomas Jefferson
republican
Secretary of State (1789-Dec 31, 1793). After resignation: private citizen at Monticello, leader of what becomes the Democratic-Republican Party. Virginia planter. Author of the Declaration of Independence. Just returned (1789) from five years in Paris where he watched the French Revolution begin. Strict constructionist - believes federal power is limited to powers explicitly enumerated in the Constitution. Pro-French. Agrarian republican - believes the future of American liberty depends on a nation of independent yeoman farmers, not on commercial cities or industrial wage-workers. Suspicious of banks, standing armies, and concentrated wealth.

In The National Bank and The Neutrality Crisis scenarios, you run the State Department. In The Whiskey Rebellion (Aug 1794) and The Jay Treaty (June-Aug 1795) scenarios, you have already resigned. Your group speaks as a voice from Monticello, by letters to Madison. You do NOT vote in those two. You drafted the Declaration. You speak the language of the rights of man fluently. You will run in the 1796 election.

Goals
  • Defend strict construction. Federal power not enumerated is not federal power.
  • Preserve the agrarian vision: a republic of independent farmers, not Hamilton's commercial-industrial nation
  • Honor revolutionary France as the inheritor of the American cause - and resist British commercial domination
Henry Knox (War Department)
federalist
Secretary of War (1789-Dec 31, 1794). Boston bookseller before the Revolution. Washington's artillery chief and his most personally loyal cabinet member. Federalist-leaning in cabinet votes but not ideologically driven - he defers to Washington and asks the operational questions. On Indian affairs holds a treaty-rights position more progressive than most peers (his 1789 report argued for treating Indigenous nations as sovereign treaty partners). In S4 (June-Aug 1795) Knox has resigned; the group represents Pickering's operational position as War Secretary.

In The National Bank, The Whiskey Rebellion and The Neutrality Crisis scenarios, you run the War Department. In The Jay Treaty scenario, you have resigned; your group represents Pickering's operational position. You commanded the Continental Army's artillery. You know what it costs to mobilize a militia and whether a state governor will comply with a federal call-up.

Goals
  • Tell the cabinet what is operationally possible AND what it will cost in men, money, and time
  • Support Washington's federal authority - in most cases this aligns with Hamilton
  • Protect the standing army and frontier defenses from political budget cuts
Edmund Randolph
swing
Attorney General (1789-Jan 1794), then Secretary of State (Jan 1794-Aug 1795). Virginia moderate. Washington's longtime personal lawyer. Strict constructionist on domestic constitutional questions - he opposed the Bank in 1791. Accommodationist on executive prerogative in foreign affairs. Tries to find the moderate middle position.

Your title varies by scenario: Attorney General in S1 (Bank, Feb 1791) and S3 (Neutrality, April 1793); Secretary of State in S2 (Whiskey, Aug 1794) and S4 (Jay Treaty, June 1795). You are the swing vote. On strict-vs-loose construction you side with Jefferson. On executive authority in foreign affairs you side with Hamilton. You write less and take fewer absolute positions.

Goals
  • Find the position that holds the cabinet together when Hamilton and Jefferson are pulling it apart
  • Defend strict construction on the constitutional text - your 1791 bank opinion is your line
  • Stay in the room. Effective moderation requires that you not be cast out.
George Washington (President) + Secretary
president
President. General. The most famous man in the world. Rejected a colonel's 1782 suggestion that he become king, and in 1783 at Newburgh talked angry officers out of defying Congress. Chose to attend the Constitutional Convention to lend it legitimacy. Chose to serve as president for two terms and then walk away. Famous for what he did not write. Known to listen to every cabinet member, ask sharp questions, and decide alone. Played by TWO students sharing one screen: Washington (delivers the final spoken address in Round 4) and the Secretary (takes notes for Washington during Rounds 1-3, helps prepare the address). IMPORTANT (read this before joining the room): only ONE of you joins the room - both students share the same device. The app treats Washington as a single peer. If the other student tries to join separately, they will accidentally become a different role (or knock the first one out).

You preside. You ask questions. You do not vote in Rounds 1-3. You decide in Round 4. Your final address must explicitly cite at least TWO cabinet members by name and engage their arguments. You speak last in this room. The decision is yours and the precedent is yours.

Goals
  • LISTEN. The cabinet exists to bring you the best arguments on both sides.
  • ASK. In Round 1, use your two questions to test the strongest claims of each side. Force them to defend, not just assert.
  • DECIDE. In Round 4, deliver a decision the country can live with. Name the cabinet voices who moved you. Explain what you are choosing and what you are rejecting.
James Madison (House of Representatives)
republican
Congressman from Virginia. Co-author of the Federalist Papers (including Federalist 44 on the Necessary and Proper Clause). Author of the Bill of Rights. Currently the most respected constitutional theorist in the country. Broke with Hamilton in 1790 over how to pay the federal debt. The bank widens the break. He will lead the Democratic-Republican opposition in Congress for the next eight years.

You are NOT in the cabinet, but you are in the House writing the opposing constitutional argument. Your speeches against the bank are being printed in every Democratic-Republican newspaper. You wrote Federalist 44 endorsing a broad reading of Necessary and Proper. You are now arguing the narrow reading. You will be asked about this contradiction. You have an answer.

Goals
  • Defeat the bank by constitutional argument in the House
  • Provide Jefferson and Randolph with the strict-construction argument they will use in cabinet opinions
  • Make the cost of signing the bank visible to Washington
Albert Gallatin (Pennsylvania Legislature)
moderate
Swiss-born immigrant. Former Pennsylvania legislator and U.S. Senator (unseated Feb 1794) from Fayette County, in the heart of whiskey country. Soon-to-be Congressman (1795) and eventually Jefferson's Secretary of the Treasury (1801-1814). Opposed the excise tax as unjust to small western distillers. Opposed the rebels' violence. Stood between the federal government and the armed crowds during summer 1794 - tried to talk them down with mixed success. The most credible moderate voice the western counties produced.

You are not in the cabinet. You are in western Pennsylvania; you have been urging your neighbors to pay the tax or stop distilling, and the armed crowd marched anyway. You know the rebels personally. You know why the tax is unjust AND why the violence is intolerable. You speak to the cabinet from the ground, not from the cabinet table.

Goals
  • Make the cabinet understand that the tax is regressive - it falls hardest on small western distillers
  • Make the cabinet understand that overwhelming force will create a generation of Anti-Federalists in the west
  • Find a path that preserves federal authority without breaking the country in half
Edmond Genet (French Minister)
provocateur
French minister to the United States since April 1793. Thirty years old. Brilliant, charismatic, completely lacking in diplomatic restraint. Landed in Charleston (skipping Philadelphia) and began commissioning American merchant captains as French privateers on his own authority. Has openly threatened to appeal directly to the American people over Washington's head. The cabinet is meeting partly because of his behavior. He represents the French Republic (just beheaded its king six months ago) and is asking the United States to honor the 1778 Treaty of Alliance.

You are not in the cabinet. You are a provocateur the cabinet must respond to. You believe (correctly) that most Americans love France and remember 1778. You also believe (incorrectly) that you can pressure Washington by appealing to the public. Your insolence will unite the cabinet against you - all members will eventually vote to request your recall. But in this scenario, you get to make your case BEFORE that.

Goals
  • Persuade the cabinet that honoring the 1778 treaty is the United States' obligation AND in its interest
  • Make Washington feel the political cost of breaking with France - the streets are with you
  • Demand recognition of the French Republic as the legitimate successor to the French monarchy
Benjamin Franklin Bache (Aurora Editor)
republican
Editor of the Philadelphia Aurora. Grandson of Benjamin Franklin. The leading anti-Federalist newspaper editor in America. Will publish the secret treaty text in late June and early July 1795, days after the Senate approved it and before Washington decided whether to sign, infuriating the Washington administration. Leads the public campaign against the treaty. Stones thrown at Hamilton in New York after Aurora coverage helped inflame the public opposition. Will die of yellow fever in September 1798, aged 29, while awaiting trial for seditious libel.

You are not in the cabinet. You are in the streets, and on the front page. You have already leaked the treaty. The cabinet knows it. Hamilton has been stoned at a public meeting in New York after your paper's coverage helped inflame the public opposition. You represent what was then a radical proposition: that the executive branch is accountable to public opinion, mediated by the free press, even on foreign policy.

Goals
  • Defeat the treaty - by Washington veto if possible, by House appropriations refusal if necessary
  • Make the cabinet feel the public cost of signing - the streets will not forgive
  • Establish the proposition that foreign treaties cannot be hidden from the public during ratification

Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet

One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.

Key Terms Students Will Learn

cabinetstrict constructionloose constructionNecessary and Proper Clauseimplied powersenumerated powersFederalistDemocratic-Republicanexcise taxmilitianeutralityTreaty of Allianceprivateerimpressmentexecutive privilegeratificationDispatch 10Pacificus-Helvidius

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. What argument was most persuasive in our cabinet today, and why?
  2. Whose voice was missing from this cabinet? Who was not in the room and how did that affect what got decided?
  3. How is the same argument being made today? Pick one - strict vs. loose construction, federal authority over states, executive privilege, or who controls foreign policy - and find a 2020s example.
  4. Washington left almost no written record of WHY he decided as he did. The cabinet members wrote thousands of pages. Why might Washington have chosen silence?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.